When to give a closing gift
Most agents hand over the gift at the closing table or drop it off in the first week after move-in. Both work. At closing, the buyers are busy signing and juggling keys, so a gift that ships to the new address a few days later often gets more of their attention.
If you want it in hand at closing, order 2 to 4 weeks ahead. For our Manhattan puzzle, we email a proof within 1 to 2 business days, make it in up to 10 business days after you approve it, and US shipping takes 2 to 5 business days. For Christmas delivery, order by December 3, 2026.
How much agents usually spend
No survey sets one number. Agent blogs, trainers and gift vendors put the typical closing gift at about $50 to $200, and a few go up to $300. Some trainers tie it to the commission and suggest anywhere from 0.5% to 5% of it. One broker coach quoted by realtor.com argued for $50 or less.
Pick a number you can repeat for every buyer, since past clients talk to each other. One point that comes up often: the IRS limits the business gift deduction to $25 per person per year, and many agents spend more anyway. How that applies to you is a question for your accountant.
What makes a closing gift personal
A personal gift points to this house and this family. Three details do most of the work: their name, their street and the year they got the keys. A gift with all three can only belong to them.
Keep your own branding small. Gift guides for agents warn that a large logo makes a gift read like an ad. A small logo, or a short line such as A gift from Jane Doe, is enough for them to remember who sent it. Last, pick something they will use in the first week and keep after, so it stays in the house and out of a drawer.
Manhattan details that make it theirs
Our Manhattan puzzle maps the island from Inwood down to the harbor, turned so the avenues run straight up the puzzle, with the Hudson on one side and the East River on the other. The landmark tiles include the Statue of Liberty, South Street Seaport, the Brooklyn Bridge, the Washington Square Arch, Little Island, the High Line, Grand Central Terminal, the New York Public Library, Times Square, St. Patrick's Cathedral, Bethesda Fountain, the Met, the Guggenheim Museum, Columbia University, the Apollo Theater and the Met Cloisters. The map covers Manhattan only, so for a home in Brooklyn, Queens or another borough, message us on Etsy before you order.
The Home Style menu has 15 Manhattan options: Prewar Co-op, Postwar White-Brick, Doorman Building, Glass High-Rise, Brownstone, Walk-Up Tenement, New Development, Art Deco Prewar, Cast-Iron Loft, Converted Warehouse, Townhouse, Harlem Brownstone, Penthouse, Garden Apartment and Federal Rowhouse. For an apartment, tell us the floor and we add a small heart on a window of that floor. For a doorman building, the front desk can sign for the box.
Our Manhattan closing gift
The Manhattan map puzzle is $65, or $75 with your logo. It is a personalized puzzle with the buyer's style of building drawn on their block, a heart on the spot, their family name and the year. If you want a second, smaller piece for their first holiday in the house, the ornament and framed map print below are personalized and made to order too.



Questions we get
- How far ahead should I order a closing gift?
- Allow about 2 to 4 weeks. We email a proof within 1 to 2 business days, make the puzzle in up to 10 business days after you approve it, and US shipping takes 2 to 5 business days.
- Can I add my logo?
- Yes. Pick a + My Logo design from the Design menu ($75 instead of $65). After you order, send your logo through Etsy messages or tell us your website. It sits small above the city name, so it shows on the box lid too.
- Can it ship straight to my client?
- Yes. You can ship it to yourself or to your client's new address. One order ships to one address, so check out once for each client.
- What if their Manhattan home doesn't match a style in the menu?
- Pick the closest one. You will see the drawing on your proof before anything prints, and you can ask for changes then.
Buying for a friend or family member instead? See our Housewarming gifts for a new home in Manhattan guide, or browse all gift guides.
